Babylon's Favorite Italian Bakery

What Does True Italian Pastry
Feel Like?

From flaky, buttery cannoli to celebration cakes handcrafted with decades of passion — every bite at Mario's carries the warmth of a family kitchen in Italy, right here on East Main Street.

Explore Our Pastries Call Us Today
Fresh
Baked Daily
Italian
Traditional Recipes
Babylon
Locally Loved
Fresh Italian pastries displayed in a warm bakery case at Mario's Pasticceria
Artisan baker shaping fresh pasta at Mario's Pasticceria
Steaming espresso cup beside fresh cannoli on a marble counter
Assorted Italian pastries including zeppole and bignè on display
Warm interior of Mario's Pasticceria with customers enjoying coffee
Our Story

A Family Tradition
Baked Into Every
Single Bite

Mario's Pasticceria wasn't born from a business plan — it was born from a kitchen table, a grandmother's recipes, and the conviction that the best things in life are made slowly, by hand, and shared generously.

Today, our bakery sits on East Main Street in the heart of Babylon, where the aroma of freshly baked cannoli and rich espresso greets everyone who walks through our door. We honor the traditions passed down through generations, using the same techniques, the same quality ingredients, and the same love for the craft.

Authentic Recipes
Passed down for generations
Made with Love
Every piece, by hand
Baked Fresh Daily
Early morning, every day
Community Rooted
Proudly serving Babylon
What We Offer

Our Signature
Specialties

Every item on our counter tells a story — from the crisp shell of a cannoli to the velvet crumb of our tiramisù. Here's what makes Mario's unforgettable.

Golden cannoli shells filled with sweet ricotta cream, dusted with cocoa
Bestseller

Cannoli

Crisp, fried shells piped fresh with velvety sweet ricotta, finished with pistachios or chocolate chips. Made to order, every single day.

Layers of mascarpone cream and espresso-soaked ladyfingers in a glass dish

Tiramisù

Our signature tiramisù is built with strong espresso, silky mascarpone cream, and a dusting of Valrhona cocoa. The kind that makes you close your eyes.

Rich espresso poured from a traditional Italian machine into a small cup

Espresso & Caffè

Sourced from Italian roasters and pulled on a commercial espresso machine. From a quick ristretto to a creamy cappuccino — perfection in every cup.

Crusty artisan Italian bread loaves cooling on a wooden rack

Artisan Bread

From classic focaccia to crusty ciabatta and sweet cornetto — our bread is mixed, proofed, and baked fresh each morning using traditional methods.

Golden fried zeppole pastries dusted with powdered sugar on a plate

Zeppole & Bignè

Pillowy clouds of fried dough, light as air and dusted with powdered sugar. A Neapolitan classic that disappears fast — we recommend coming early.

Square Sicilian sfincione pizza topped with tomatoes, onions, and caciocavallo

Sfincione & Focaccia

Sicilian-style sfincione with a thick, pillowy crust, tangy tomato sauce, onions, and melted caciocavallo. Comfort food at its most honest.

Custom Celebration Cakes

Your Milestone,
Our Craft

Whether it's a wedding that calls for an elegant tiered masterpiece, a baptism cake adorned with delicate sugar flowers, or a birthday that needs to be unforgettable — we design and bake every celebration cake from scratch, tailored to your vision.

We work with you from the first sketch to the final decoration, using premium ingredients and time-honored techniques. No two cakes are alike — because no two celebrations are.

  • Wedding & engagement cakes
  • Baptism, communion & confirmation
  • Birthdays, anniversaries & holidays
  • Custom flavors & dietary options
Order Your Custom Cake
Elegant multi-tier celebration cake decorated with Italian-inspired details at Mario's Pasticceria
Come Visit Us

We're Waiting
to Welcome You

Our Location

199 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702-3536

Get Directions

Call Us

For custom cake orders, catering inquiries, or any questions — we're happy to help.

(631) 539-8636

Hours

Monday – Thursday 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Friday – Saturday 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Ready to Taste the Difference?

Stop by 199 E Main St and let us surprise you. Or call ahead to place your order — your favorite pastries are waiting.

Call (631) 539-8636 Get Directions
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website